Dr. Byrne’s Honest Response To The NY Times Article, ‘The Selling of Attention Deficit Disorder’.

On Sunday 12/15/13, the NY Times ran a headline article “The Selling of Attention Deficit Disorder”. This long article opened with a quote from Dr Keith Connors after addressing a group of ADHD specialists in Washington (the APSARD conference). As a member of this group, I would like to respond to this article and what it means for adults with attention problems.

The article discussed how the pharmaceutical industry has been pushing stimulant medications for ADHD on children for years, and how they are now trying to push stimulant medications for ADHD on adults. It reports that this process has “led to too many people with scant symptoms receiving the diagnosis and medication”.

In private practice, many adults come to me for help with attention problems. Some have ADHD and make remarkable changes in their life with treatment. Some do not have ADHD and it is my job to figure out what other problems are causing a change in their attention. Rarely, someone will request ADHD medications for “performance enhancement”, stating they do not have ADHD but want to take stimulant medication to perform better at school or work.

So how can a doctor figure out who has adult ADHD? The NY Times article gives examples of rushed primary care doctors making an ADHD diagnosis in 5 minutes and handing out stimulant medications with no further workup. This is a poor substitute for a complete ADHD workup which should include the following:

1. Clinical examination and history. This cannot and should not be done in 5-15 minutes. A complete examination should take at least 45 minutes and should include a complete psychiatric history, a family history, a substance abuse history, and a sleep history. In theory, a primary care doctor can make this assessment but in most primary care settings this kind of time and depth is simply not an option for the doctor.

2. Subjective report. This should include a detailed report by the patient during the clinical examination and also a normed self-report rating scale (not the short quizzes described by the NY Times article). Ideally, this would also include a subjective rating scale from a second person who knows the patient well (parent or spouse, etc).

3. Objective report. There are several options ways to quantify attention problems in adults, including neuropsychological testing and computer tests of attention. These tests are objective, and are similar to ordering a blood test or an EKG to evaluate medical problems.

If you have been diagnosed with ADHD and have not had this workup you should consider finding a doctor who will complete your workup. This is extremely important because if you are having attention problems that are NOT due to ADHD, taking ADHD medications may actually make your problem worse.

I would like to also add that the NY Times article focused on treatment with stimulant medications but it is important to remember that there are other options for treatment of ADHD in adults, including nonstimulant medications, lifestyle changes, and cognitive behavior therapy (a form of talk therapy).

If you are interested in learning more about these treatment options, please watch my videos on ADHD or contact me for more information.

Warm Regards,
Dr. Jennie Byrne, MD, PhD

Author
Dr. Jennie Byrne, M.D., PhD. With over 15 years of medical expertise, Jennie Byrne, MD, PhD, is a board-certified psychiatrist with experience treating mental health conditions in adults, including dementia, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, anxiety, and depression. After practicing in New York City for 12 years, Dr. Byrne relocated to North Carolina in 2008; she currently cares for patients in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, at Cognitive Psychiatry of Chapel Hill. Dr. Byrne earned her bachelor’s degree at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. She then received her doctorate from New York University Department of Neurophysiology. She also has a doctorate of medicine from New York University School of Medicine. Dr. Byrne went on to complete a psychiatry residency at Mt. Sinai School of Medicine in New York. In addition to her work as a psychiatrist, Dr. Byrne has performed extensive research on attention, memory, and depression. As a board-certified adult psychiatrist, Dr. Byrne focuses on the needs of each patient to pro

You Might Also Enjoy...

Why Wellness?

We are so excited to share with you our self-paced, online wellness program! Learn more from Dr Byrne about this program and how CPCH wellness can help you achieve your mental health goals! www.cpchwellness.thinkific.com

Meet Jessica Booth - CPCH psychotherapist

We are excited to welcome Jessica Booth, LMFT, LCAS-A as our newest provider! Jessica is a full-time integrated CPCH team member who focuses on helping patients individually, as a couple, as a family, or in support groups. Please welcome Jessica!

How to find contentment in your daily life

Therapist Jessica Booth provides a brief introduction on how to find contentment in daily life and feed your spirit! Try these tips to feel more present and rejuvenated in your every day life.

Video Blog - What is TMS?

In this video blog, Dr Byrne talks with Dr Hernandez about Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS). Learn more about this non-medication treatment option for depression!

Video Blog - What is Alpha-Stim

In this video blog, Dr Byrne talks with Pat Boyle about Alpha-Stim, a device that can help people with depression, anxiety, and insomnia.